Water at a premium price in Liévin with Veolia: 5 times higher in a household budget than in Paris

Photo of author
Ecrit par cocostar

Local paradox: while water consumption is among the lowest in France, the bill remains steep due to a prohibitive price per cubic meter. In Liévin, the water bill weighs 5 times more in a household’s budget than in Paris.

According to the results of a recent survey published by the French Institute of the Environment (IFEN), domestic consumption in France (in 2004) reached 165 liters per inhabitant per day (i.e., 60 m3 per year), increasing by 1% per year since 2001.(1)

However, Nord Pas-de-Calais remains the most economical region with a daily average of 122 liters (44 m3 per year), compared to nearly double in Provence Alpes Côte d’Azur. The cubic meter of water (1,000 liters) costs on average €3.01 in France. From 2001 to 2004, the average rate increased by 2.4% per year, which is more than the price increase over the same period (2%).

In the Pas-de-Calais department, the average is around €3.60, placing the sector among the most expensive in the country. The cause is wastewater treatment, which represents for example 43% of the Liévin bill (€1.61 per cubic meter).

Liévin and Veolia, a long history.
The water distribution has been entrusted, for many years, to the Compagnie Générale des Eaux (now known by the gentle name of Veolia Environnement, since the drowning of Vivendi). As with any sector whose distribution is subject to a delegation contract, the cubic meter is logically much more expensive there (€3.69) than when water distribution is managed directly by the municipality (€2.19 on average). The only positive aspect: the subscription price in Liévin is in the lower range (€52.56 including tax per year), compared to a national average of €56.

Lire aussi :  Does a water softener require an installation permit

Water, a luxury product in Liévin?
For a couple with one child, with consumption “within the regional average” (122 liters per day per inhabitant), the annual bill will amount to €543 (of which €490 corresponds to a consumption of 133 cubic meters). With similar consumption, a Parisian couple with a child (2) will pay only €379 (€164 less)

According to INSEE, the average annual income per household in Liévin is €10,698. The water bill therefore represents more than 5% of household expenses alone (compared to 1% in Paris, considering an average income of more than €25,948 and a lower bill). The “water” budget thus weighs 5 times more heavily on a Liévin household than on a Parisian couple with a child.

nitrates: an unequal battle
Human activity is the cause of nitrate pollution of various groundwater tables, to varying degrees: some sites exceed the threshold of 50 milligrams per liter, and sometimes reach 100 milligrams in some places. For a long time, industries were blamed, but it seems that the origin of these high nitrate levels is mainly linked to the illegal discharge of wastewater by the inhabitants themselves (absence of sewer systems and especially treatment plants).

From April 2003 to June 2004, eight denitrification units were installed around production sites, at an estimated cost of 10 million Euros: the cost of the units was borne by the Compagnie Générale des Eaux (€6 million), while the intercommunality took charge of operation and connection (€4 million). Since 2004, these installations have caused an increase of €0.17 per cubic meter on the already high bills for the inhabitants of the agglomeration. In Liévin, the Equipages site was the first to benefit from these units announced as “revolutionary,” but “temporary.” By the way, what is meant by “temporary”?

denitrification plants: water… or hot air?
The water distributed in Liévin has resulted for decades from a mixture between water from the Rollencourt aquifer (deeper and naturally less nitrated) and water from the Equipages aquifer (which passes through the denitrification plant). In February and March of this year, tap analyses showed nitrate levels ranging from 26 to 38 milligrams per liter (below the standard of 50 mg/l). Not so bad, you might say. But we found an analysis dating from 1989 (when denitrification plants were not yet known) issued by the Pasteur Institute of Lille. It shows that nitrates in the water delivered to Liévin were present at… 38.4 mg/liter. The same figure as the DDASS analysis of February 13, 2007. One can doubt the current effectiveness of the denitrification plant, while the people of Liévin continue to pay “full price” for it…

Lire aussi :  Softener size

We understand well, the miracle does not exist. It will take decades for the traces of these nitrates, consequences of our past laxity, to disappear. Provided we better manage our discharges. Today, some inhabitants of the former mining basin are still not connected to the sewer network and continue to discharge their wastewater into nature with impunity. We have not yet completely broken the vicious circle of pollution and will still have to suffer the consequences, for lack of being able to control the causes. Which will continue to make the fortune of those who claim to hold “the miracle solution” to get rid of the cumbersome nitrates…

Daniel Ludwikowski, Deputy and Green Elected Official: A Political Choice

Daniel Ludwikowski, Deputy and Green Elected Official: A Political Choice

Daniel Ludwikowski is Deputy for Sustainable Development of the Territory in the city of Liévin and an elected member of the Green party.

Vincent Pihen :

  • Can you really drink tap water in Liévin?

D.L.: Yes, if we refer to the latest analyses which comply with current standards. Water quality has long been a real problem in the territory but also throughout the mining basin. Ten to twenty years ago, diesel or even cyanide was still found in groundwater, and I am not even talking about the state of river water. Since then, the city and the agglomeration community have taken many measures to protect the various water points but also to clean up the distribution water network. The Lens-Liévin Communaupole even hired a hydrogeologist, which is not common, with the aim of finding new sources.

  • V.P: The value for money of drinking water seems quite unbalanced. For you, what is the reason?
Lire aussi :  What are the effects of hard water on pipes

D.L.: Three actors are involved in water management in Liévin: the city, the agglomeration community, and the distributor, Veolia, the world’s leading water services operator. Quality is not the primary goal sought by the private group but indeed profit. Veolia considers water as a commodity and does not really advocate transparency when it comes to discussing quality and maintenance costs.

  • V.P: This debate about management actually hides a real societal problem…

D.L.: The vision we defend, among the Greens, is to consider water as a right. It is a real political choice. The management of the drinking water network must be administered by a true public service. I find it strange that the issue of electricity management gives rise to many debates but not that of water. Yet, we live longer without electricity than without water. It is a crucial issue, especially for the years to come.

  • V.P: How do you see the future of water management in Liévin and its surroundings?

D.L.: The first battle will be to make my colleagues understand the danger of such a situation. Today, precariousness affects more and more people in our region. People should pay half as much for better quality water. The agglomeration community has all the cards in hand because it must renew the sanitation contracts in two years and all contracts with Veolia in eight years. Some agglomerations like Grenoble or Bordeaux have reversed course and returned to a public service. Why not us?

Leave a Comment